The roll & shift does add randomness, but so does the roll & gather assets in Settlers of Catan. The appealing thing in Catan is you can fiddle with the numbers to raise your range of 'great numbers', or it is possible to improve the payoff on sure numbers. - https://lo-de-online63062.smblogsites.com/39668452/what-does-what-determines-movement-and-outcomes-in-roll-and-move-games-mean